I'm at the part of the quest where the Nehrimise have invaded the town and you follow Arantheal for a bit. You find that the gate is jammed and you and he have to fix it. In a video of someone else's playthrough, I saw what was supposed to happen: Arantheal opens the door and you follow him through it.
In my game, he instead runs to the right of the door and just stands there, facing the wall. I can talk to him but he doesn't have anything of note to say. I tried going through the door but it's barred from the other side for some reason??? So I'm stuck.
I tried reloading an old save (specifically just before the fight with the Oorbaya that Rynéus turns into). I redid the fight, teleported to the Sun temple (using a scroll) to do a few errands and stock up on potions, sleep for an hour to heal, etc. Then I gave the black stone to the monocle dude and redid everything all over again only to have him ONCE AGAIN go to the right of the door instead of opening it.
I don't use mods, I have the Special Edition version of the game, and I didn't mess with console commands during this quest. Save file attached.
Edit: Used a more recent save file