How does Sarantha fit within the Cycle? [SPOILERS]

[UngodlyGod]

In Enderal, it is stated that each cycle will follow a certain path before ending with the Cleansing.
[1] Life begins anew
[2] Evolution begets humanity
[3] A natural disaster
[4] A few people become Gods (Light-born, Sun-priests)
[5] The Gods are overthrown
[6] The Cleansing

In Nehrim however, there's a cycle of Light and Dark masterminded by fate itself, Sarantha.
She is fate personified, and she controls the fate of all mortals, even the Light-born. Doesn't that mean that she's more powerful than the High Ones, who can only manipulate people through visions and dreams?
How does the existence of Sarantha, the Heart of The World, The Shadow World, and her cycle of Light and Dark fit in any of this? I'm confused as hell.

[Stampfer]

I look at this in a rather profane way. Each of these games tell their own story. A greater theme (in regards to Enderal everything revolves around the fragility of the psyche) is just embedded in a fantasy setting. They share the same universe but I believe the theme was deemed more important than logical consistency between Enderal and Nehrim.
Still, it doesn't hurt (and may be fun in itself) to make theories how all this could be connected.

[Glycerin]

I played Nehrim quite a long time ago, so I may be wrong about this, but didn't we kill Sarantha? With Fate out of the way, there would be much fewer logical problems.
But then again we have the Veiled Woman in Enderal, who plays fate on more than one occasion. I don't know if she really is a representation of fate or something else entirely, but maybe Sarantha as a person wasn't all that important and it is more about the concept, which still persists after her death, just in another form. That would also mean you never actually freed yourself from fate, as Nehrim's ending suggested. That also fits in nicely with the question you are presented at Enderal's intro "What distinguishes a free man from a slave?" if the answer is that you can never truly escape your fate. Or I am just overanalyzing things here, I guess I better stop now

[UngodlyGod]

@Stampfer
Yeah, it'll be fun trying to connect the dots, just like the Soulsborne series.

@Glycerin
Yeah, we did kill Sarantha, but I'm talking about the relevance of the Light-born Shadow-god Cycle to Enderal's Cleansing Cycle.
In Nehrim, if I'm not mistaken, the Light-born's existence created an imbalance in the world, and fate decreed that they have to be taken down by the Shadow-gods. Once the Light-born are dead, now it's the Shadow-gods' existence creates an imbalance in the world, so now Fate sends her envoys to kill the Shadow-gods until they're dead.
So I assume that after the Shadow-gods are dead, new Light-born would rise and the cycle repeats itself, maybe? Since Nehrim hinted that this cylce had been continuing for ages, until we kill Sarantha.

====================[SPECULATION]====================

Maybe Sarantha created her Light-Dark cycle to indefinitely delay the High Ones' cycle? She resides in the Shadow World, a place containing the ruins of worlds ruined by imbalance, as well as some ghosts. These ruins are probably the ruins of past civilizations which were destroyed by The Cleansing and the ghosts there are probably those who died but weren't absorbed. The imbalance mentioned is probably the requirements for The Cleansing to happen.

The absence of the false gods is necessary for The Cleansing to happen; so by turning the existence of the false gods into a cycle, Sarantha made sure that The Cleansing will never happen, since new false gods will forever replace the old ones, creating a perpetual presence of false gods.

But in Nehrim, we killed her and ended her little cycle, so The Cleansing's Cycle is now able to progress naturally.
If this speculation is somewhat correct; since Sarantha is against The Cleansing, and The Veiled Woman too is against The Cleansing, they could very well be the same person. Note that The Veiled Woman talked about "the probabilities are against you" on board Rocio's ship. Though why she didn't bring us to the Machine earlier is still a big question.

=================[SPECULATION ENDS]=================

Although this theory doesn't explain why Sarantha is such a b*tch.

[badgesareus]

Better lay off the peaceweed!

I just had a couple of random thoughts after reading this.
(1) There are several mentions in Enderal of the death of the false gods, but I don't recall any mentions of the shadow god; I thought that odd.
(2) I wonder why, in the tunnels below Ark near the end, there was that vision of Teleor (sorry spelled it wrong I'm sure) and his false-god lover (what was her name, Iranda or something?).
(3) Could it be that Sarantha was also a High One and they had some falling out so she decided to mess with them?
(4) It's been a long time since I played Nehrim, but remember you had to destroy some crucial book in the firey depths of the world? Maybe that had some greater significance beyond Nehrim.

[UngodlyGod]

Better lay off the peaceweed!

I just had a couple of random thoughts after reading this.
(1) There are several mentions in Enderal of the death of the false gods, but I don't recall any mentions of the shadow god; I thought that odd.
(2) I wonder why, in the tunnels below Ark near the end, there was that vision of Teleor (sorry spelled it wrong I'm sure) and his false-god lover (what was her name, Iranda or something?).
(3) Could it be that Sarantha was also a High One and they had some falling out so she decided to mess with them?
(4) It's been a long time since I played Nehrim, but remember you had to destroy some crucial book in the firey depths of the world? Maybe that had some greater significance beyond Nehrim.

[1] There is, the Nehrimese mage, Constantine told you that he helped Narathzul Arantheal and The Shadow-god to destroy the Light-born. He mentions this once only though.
[2] That vision was shown to reinforce the traitor's resolve to destroy the Numinos (to ruin Tealor into activating the Beacon).
[3] Nope, that couldn't be since the High Ones lack physical form, and they can't interfere except through posession and manipulation.
[4] Maybe, that place is connected to other world(s). The only way to destroy the book is to destroy it at that place.

[Ranvena]

In Nehrim however, there's a cycle of Light and Dark masterminded by fate itself, Sarantha.

Maybe I misunderstood this during my play-through of Nehrim, but wasn't Sarantha just an emissary of fate, not fate itself?

[+]

That is interesting to think about, if that's the case, since the player in Enderal is mentioned as an emissary too - which seems to translate to a piece in a chess game according to how the story is worded at certain points.

If an 'emissary' is used in the same way here, then wouldn't that mean that Sarantha was also just a piece in the game and not the hand that moves them?

[UngodlyGod]

Maybe I misunderstood this during my play-through of Nehrim, but wasn't Sarantha just an emissary of fate, not fate itself?

If she's just an emissary of fate, killing her would be pointless, wouldn't it?
The main reason for destroying the Book of Predestination was to free everyone from fate and destiny. But destroying the book wasn't enough, since we were sent to the Shadow World to confront her. She even declares herself Fate, and has always been our true enemy. In the end, we killed her and everyone is finally free from fate and mankind can now progress through their own choice.

[+]

That is interesting to think about, if that's the case, since the player in Enderal is mentioned as an emissary too - which seems to translate to a piece in a chess game according to how the story is worded at certain points.

If an 'emissary' is used in the same way here, then wouldn't that mean that Sarantha was also just a piece in the game and not the hand that moves them?

As I said above, I'm pretty sure she wasn't an emissary of fate, but fate personified.
I don't think she's with the High Ones or was used by them, because she made and sustained her own Cycle of The Gods to prevent the world from falling into "imbalance". Sarantha herself said that the Shadow World represents the ruins of worlds that perished due to "imbalance". Maybe the "imbalance" she mentioned is The Cleansing.

Since Arkt and our Nehrim character are still Shadow-gods after we killed Sarantha, that means The False Deities only refer to those who are worshiped by the majority of the world's population. Without Sarantha's cycle, there won't be any new False Deities, and so The Cleansing's cycle can progress naturally.

[Cyrenne]

I remember, there was this book in Nehrim, Der erste Krieg, für Schöpfer und Schicksal (sorry, german >_< Should be The first war, for creator and fate (or something like that)).

In the end, the Eliath, creators of fate... strings(?), chose her (Sarantha) for a higher purpose.

And, didn't we kill an Eliath during the main quest? (it's been a while^^ but that's nothing to do with the question or anything.)

So, the creators of the fate strings (I'll call them that, for the time being, as I haven't played the english version and don't know how it was translated), chose her to be the emissary of fate, probably. Because I don't think they would make her fate itself... would they even be able to?

[UngodlyGod]

I remember, there was this book in Nehrim, Der erste Krieg, für Schöpfer und Schicksal (sorry, german >_< Should be The first war, for creator and fate (or something like that)).

In the end, the Eliath, creators of fate... strings(?), chose her (Sarantha) for a higher purpose.

And, didn't we kill an Eliath during the main quest? (it's been a while^^ but that's nothing to do with the question or anything.)

So, the creators of the fate strings (I'll call them that, for the time being, as I haven't played the english version and don't know how it was translated), chose her to be the emissary of fate, probably. Because I don't think they would make her fate itself... would they even be able to?

Well, that is rather confusing.
Does that mean our actions in Nehrim was pointless in the end? Since we didn't free the world from fate and predestination.